Les omnibus Marvel en VO que vous attendez!

Le site Marvel Masterworks Message Board lance un grand “sondage” sur ce qu attendent les lecteurs marvel en omnibus.
Ils semblent faire cela chaque année et certains suggestions se sont retrouvées (par chance?) publiées l année d’aprés. Cette année, ils veulent un maximum de participants et donc on peut voter par mail:

[quote]Ladies, Gentleman, Ruffians, and Scoundrels;

Its the time honored tradition of letting the Marvel community know what our most wanted Omnibus’ are. There is only one major change this year.

Please send your votes to MarvelOmniSecretBallot(at)gmail.com

By creating a separate email account it allows for more inclusion, for those who lurk, and for those who can reach out to others whom have comic based podcasts or websites, comic shops, or even other friends who want to partake. I am striving to maintain a minimum of 150+ voters but honestly would love to catalpult the number of participants to the next level. The more votes we get, the better our sample—heck if we get enough votes to merit it, I would be willing to do a Top 100.

Just rank your ten choices from number 1–(your most wanted) through number 10 and then send them to me in an email.

Your 1st place vote is worth 10 points, 2nd place gets 9 points… and your 10th place vote is worth 1 point.

  1. 10 points
  2. 9 points
  3. 8 points
  4. 7 points
  5. 6 points
  6. 5 points
  7. 4 points
  8. 3 points
  9. 2 points
  10. 1 point

Please bump the thread once you have voted, so the link stays on the front page.

Please be as specific as possible in your choices… If you want a Black Panther Omnibus make sure you make it clear that you mean either Kirby’s, Priest’s, or Hudlin’s run, or maybe you meant Jungle Action. Be as detailed as you can in your votes unless you feel it is self explanatory. Dont say Peter David’s Hulk, the man wrote it for nearly two decades. Please break it down by issue numbers and/or long running artist if applicable. Any book that was previously licensed by Marvel is eligible for voting as are defunct lines (Epic) and purchased properties (Crossgen, etc.)

Most importantly, this is a SECRET ballot, do not post your complete list on the thread as it does take the fun out of it a bit. If you would like to nominate something that did not make the TOP 50 last year so it jogs people’s memories, I will allow for that.

Ten of the omnibus from last years poll have been released or solicited since the results.

Last Day to Vote will be Midnight Eastern time on May 7th. Happy Voting[/quote]

Pour ceux que ca intéresse.
marvelmasterworksfansite.yuku.co … Qnv23q5q70

Résultats

We have enough for a Top 60, so that is what is planned. I will reveal more later today.

#60 What If? (1st Series) 1-25
#59 House of M
#58 Captain Marvel by Peter David (Volume 1)
#57 X-Force by Kyle and Yost
#56 Sub-Mariner- Silver Age
#55 X-Force Volume 3 (32-43, Cable Issues)
#54 Conan the Barbarian
#53 Thor God of Thunder
#52 Incredible Hercules
#51 Spider-Man Brand New Day
#50 Ghost Rider (1990’s) by Howard Mackie
#49 Captain America Volume #3
#48 Doctor Strange by Roger Stern
#47 Marvel Horror Anthology
#46 Killraven Complete
#45 Captain America by Mark Gruenwald
#44 Runaways by BKV
#43 Superior Spider-Man
#42 Punisher by Greg Rucka
#41 Black Panther by Priest
#40 West Coast Avengers
#39 Amazing Spider-Man by JMS
#38 (TIE) Avengers by Hickman Volume 2
#38 (TIE) Wolverine by Larry Hama (#31-57)
#37 X-Factor (1986) by Peter David
#36 Generation X
#35 Micronauts Vol 1
#34 Alpha Flight Vol 2
#33 (TIE) Wolverine by Jason Aaron Vol 2
#33 (TIE) Iron Man by Micheline Vol 2
#32 Silver Surfer by Steve Englehart
#31 (TIE) Shadowland Complete
#31 (TIE) X-Factor (1986)
#30 She Hulk by Dan Slott
#29 Spectacular Spider-Man by Dematteis
#28 Wolverine Vol 2 (11-30, extras)
#27 Namor by Byrne
#26 Ghost Rider- Blaze (1970s)
#25 X-Men Legacy by Carey Vol 1
#24 Amazing Spider-Man by Micheline and Bagley
#23 Incredible Hulk (Silver Age) Volume 2
#22 She Hulk by Byrne
#21 Moon Knight by Moench
#20 Dr. Strange Silver Age Volume 2
#19 Avengers by Roger Stern Volume 1
#18 Infinity War
#17 New Warriors Volume 2
#16 Rom Volume 1
#15 X-Factor (2006) by David Volume 1
#14 Miracleman
#13 Ultimate Spider-Man Volume 2
#12 Daredevil by Nocenti
#11 Thunderbolts
#10 Punisher Max
#9 New Avengers Volume 2
#8 Avengers Silver Age Volume 3
#7 Fantastic Four Volume 4
#6 Excalibur Volume 1
#5 Amazing Spider-Man Volume 4
#4 Incredible Hulk by Peter David Volume 1
#3 X-Men Before the Fall
#2 New Mutants Volume 1
#1 Uncanny X-Men Volume 4

[quote]And now, those who just missed the list…
Spectacular Spider-Man Volume 1
Invicible Iron Man by Fraction
Fantastic Four by Mark Waid
Uncanny X-Men by Kieron Gillen
Dazzler
Academy X/New Mutants by Defillipis and Weir
Silver Surfer by Slott
Amazing Spider-Man by Defalco
Infinity Crusade
Steve Ditko’s "Monsters"
Spider-Girl
Defenders
Secret Avengers
Vision by King[/quote]

marvelmasterworksfansite.yuku.co … RIh0NSLRkg

Tiens, un top 60 avec 63 entrées…
Normalement, les ex-aequo décalent le rang des suivants : le Silver Surfer d’Englehart aurait dû être trente-troisième et décaler tous les suivants (et le top 60 devrait donc s’arrêter à X-Force).

Tori.

Et ben les mutants ont la cote, c’est plutôt cool !

C est reparti

Hello everyone, friends new and old, it’s that time of the year-- the one where everyone pleads their cases and casts their SECRET ballots for the Most Wanted Marvel Omnibus. This past year saw quite a few selections make it to fruition including

Ben Reilly Omnibus 2
Ditko Master of Suspense 2
She Hulk by Byrne
Hulk by David Vol 1
Infinity Crusade
Excalibur
New Mutants

6 Books will see the light of day by the years end, and that means a minimum of 9 new entries on the Most Wanted List, with several others rumored to be solicited but nothing official through solicitations

How it works…Just rank your ten choices from number 1–(your most wanted) through number 10 and then send them to me in an email.

Your 1st place vote is worth 10 points, 2nd place gets 9 points… and your 10th place vote is worth 1 point.

  1. 10 points
  2. 9 points
  3. 8 points
  4. 7 points
  5. 6 points
  6. 5 points
  7. 4 points
  8. 3 points
  9. 2 points
  10. 1 point

By creating a separate email account it allows for more inclusion, for those who lurk, and for those who can reach out to others whom have comic based podcasts or websites, comic shops, or even other friends who want to partake. I am striving to maintain a minimum of 200+ voters but honestly would love to catapult the number of participants to the next level. The more votes we get, the better our sample. PLEASE TELL EVERYONE YOU KNOW ABOUT THE POLL.

Please send your votes to MarvelOmniSecretBallot@gmail.com.

Please bump the thread once you have voted, so the link stays on the front page.

No reprints

Please be as specific as possible in your choices… If you want a Captain Marvel Omnibus…Do you want David Vol 1, David Vol2, Thompson, DeConnick or someone else/

Most importantly, this is a SECRET ballot, do not post your complete list on the thread as it does take the fun out of it a bit. If you would like to nominate something that did not make the TOP 50 last year so it jogs people’s memories, I will allow for that.

Happy Casting!!!

Last Day to Vote will be Midnight Eastern time on April 11th 2020 (or 2018 if you get your time machine working :))

C est bientôt le 11/04!

#60 GHOST RIDER (1990’S)
#59 (TIE) HULK BY BILL MANTLO
#59 (TIE) DAREDEVIL BY DENNY O’ NEILL
#58 SPIDER-MAN: ALIEN COSTUME SAGA
#57 X-FACTOR (1986) VOLUME 1
#56 MS. MARVEL (KAMALA KHAN) VOL 2
#55 EXCALIBUR VOLUME 2
#54 WOLVERINE BY LARRY HAMA
#53 IRON FIST CLASSIC
#52 (TIE) CAPTAIN AMERICA BY RICK REMENDER
#52 (TIE) SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN BY PETER DAVID
#51 INCREDIBLE HERCULES
#50 AVENGERS WEST COAST
#49 X-FORCE by KYLE AND YOST
#48 CAPTAIN MARVEL by DAVID
#47 INVADERS
#46 MARVEL TEAM-UP
#45 CAPTAIN MARVEL CLASSIC
#44 BLACK PANTHER by PRIEST
#43 CABLE AND X-FORCE
#42 PUNISHER (1980’S)
#41 (TIE) X-MEN THE HIDDEN YEARS
#41 (TIE) ANT-MAN SILVER AGE
#40 IRON MAN by MICHELINIE VOL 2
#39 X-TREME X-MEN
#38 CAPTAIN AMERICA by GRUENWALD
#37 WHAT IF CLASSIC
#36 CAPTAIN BRITAIN AND MI 13
#35 SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN VOL 1
#34 NEW WARRIORS VOL 2
#33 X-MEN LEGACY by CAREY
#32 NEW AVENGERS VOL 2
#31 ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN VOL 2
#30 HOUSE OF M
#29 SPIDER-MAN BRAND NEW DAY
#28 ALPHA FLIGHT VOL 2
#27 MIRACLEMAN
#26 (TIE) X-FACTOR by DAVID (1990s)
#26 (TIE) IRON MAN SILVER AGE VOL 3
#25 PUNISHER by RUCKA
#24 MICRONAUTS
#23 SUPERIOR SPIDER-MAN
#22 DAREDEVIL by SOULE
#21 DEFENDERS
#20 AVENGERS SA VOL 5
#19 DAREDEVIL SA VOL 2
#18 WOLVERINE VOL 2
#17 X-FACTOR INVESTIGATIONS
#16 (TIE) SPIDER-MAN BY DEFALCO
#16 (TIE) SUB-MARINER SA
#15 SPECTACULAR SPIDER-MAN BY DEMATTEIS
#14 SILVER SURFER BY ENGLEHART
#13 HULK SA VOL 2
#12 GENERATION X
#11 CAPTAIN AMERICA SA VOL 3
#10 AVENGERS by STERN
#9 NEW MUTANTS VOL 2
#8 ROMNIBUS
#7 DAREDEVIL by NOCENTI
#6 DOCTOR STRANGE SILVER AGE VOL 2
#5 THOR BY AARON
#4 SPIDER-MAN BY MICHELINIE AND BAGLEY
#3 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VOL 5
#2 UNCANNY X-MEN VOL 5
#1 FANTASTIC FOUR VOL 4